In a move that shocks absolutely no one, Bowl Championship Series presidents this week rejected the Mountain West Conference’s playoff plan.
The MWC proposed an eight-team playoff system that would allow greater access to the national championship game to teams outside the six most powerful leagues. The BCS presidential oversight committee rejected the concept during a teleconference on Wednesday.
“There was no overall support for the proposal, although some conferences were interested in considering certain elements of it in the future — particularly those related to revenue, access and governance of the BCS arrangement,” said University of Oregon president David Frohnmayer, the outgoing committee chairman.
The MWC is still angry that Utah went unbeaten last year and didn’t get a chance to play for the national title, while one-loss Florida and Oklahoma did. Then the Utes went out and stomped Alabama in the Sugar Bowl. Utah finished the season No. 2 in the Associated Press final poll and No. 4 in the USA Today/Coaches poll. Utah coach Kyle Whittingham voted his team No. 1.
The Mountain West’s plan would have used the current BCS bowls — Orange, Sugar, Fiesta and Rose — as well as a fifth unnamed bowl. Ultimately the teams would be whittled down until a national champion was determined.
Of course, the BCS schools and Notre Dame had no use for this, because they are getting rich off the current system. The BCS and ESPN agreed to a four-year, $500 million deal in November that will keep the current system intact. Somewhat surprisingly, all of the other mid-major conferences opposed this plan as well.
The Mountain West could see another one of its teams go unbeaten this year and be left out, as Texas Christian has a very realistic chance of running the table. Bet on the Horned Frogs futures at WagerWeb.
And the MWC isn’t done. In May, conference commissioner Craig Thompson appeared before the Subcommittee on Commerce, Trade, and Consumer Protection. Thompson says he will discuss options with the MWC Board of Directors and decide the league’s next move.
“The Mountain West appreciates the thorough review that each conference gave our reform proposal,” Thompson said in a statement Thursday. “However, the MWC continues to believe that there are fundamental flaws in the BCS system that need to be addressed. We will take yesterday’s action under advisement and consider our next steps.”
Don’t hold your breath for anything substantial to happen this decade.




